SPOILER ALERT! The plot of
the movie will be discussed.
I believe an important point
to remember about director Stanley Kubrick is that his best work is satiric.
Sometimes it is laugh-out-loud funny as in Dr.
Strangelove, or more thoughtful, as in Paths
of Glory. The first is a look at the danger of nuclear escalation during
the Cold War, the second an examination of the betrayal of soldiers by those
higher up in the military hierarchy (similar to what happens in the recently
discussed Breaker Morant).
The first forty-five minutes
of this film take place in the boot training camp at Parris Island, South
Carolina. This section is an amazing accomplishment of combining humor with
barbarity, and it is because of Ermey’s performance. His insults are numerous
and devastating, and he unleashes them like shells from a tank. For example, he
says to one recruit, “Did your parents have any children that lived?”
Homophobically, he says to Private Cowboy (Arliss Howard), who comes from
Texas, “Only steers and queers come from Texas, Private Cowboy, and you don’t
look much like a steer to me, so that kinda narrows it down.” He says there is
no prejudice at the camp, as he universally spews out ethnic slurs toward all
social and religious types.
But let’s get back to the
words “minister” and “praying” that he uses in the quote above. He often joins
the religious and the profane in his remarks. It is an ironic contrast, since
one usually associates religion with peace and brotherhood. But, as history has
shown, people can warp that message to fit a political agenda. Hartman says,
after ordering the bathroom cleaned, “I want the head so sanitary and
squared-away that the Virgin Mary herself would be proud to go in and take a
dump.” At Christmas, he tells the men, “Chaplain Charlie will tell you about
how the free world will conquer Communism with the aid of God and a few
Marines. God has a hard-on for Marines because we kill everything we see … we
keep heaven packed with fresh souls.” Notice how the comic “Charlie Chaplain”
is turned into something deadly, a priest who urges destruction of the enemy.
And, the Corps is so lethal, only a “few” Marines are necessary to get the job
done. These words are an incredible mixture of blasphemy, humor, and horror.
What it amounts to is an exhortation to wholeheartedly fight a holy war.
At the opening of the film,
we hear a song with the lyrics, “Goodbye sweetheart, hello Vietnam.” In
essence, these youths must let go of who they were, by bidding farewell to all
aspects of their past, including anyone they loved. As the song plays, we see
their hair being sheared off, like sheep (some might say, “to the slaughter.”)
This act symbolizes the discarding of individual characteristics, as they are
made to look alike, and of course, dress in identical uniforms. They must
follow orders to the point that “Marines are not allowed to die without
permission.” They lose their names, a further disintegration of identity, and take
on new ones in the form of nicknames. They must substitute flesh-and-blood
lovers with their rifles. Hartman says, “you pukes will sleep with your rifles.
You will give your rifles a girl’s name … You’re married to this piece. This
weapon of iron and wood. And you will be faithful.” The soldiers, again mixing
religion with violence, pray: “My rifle is my best friend … Without me, my
rifle is useless. Without my rifle, I am useless … Before God, I swear this
creed: my rifle and myself are defenders of my country, we are the masters of
our enemy, and we are the saviors of my life. So be it, until there is no
enemy, but peace. Amen.” They are being conditioned to see themselves as
“useless” unless they are performing the act of killing. The ending of this
“prayer,” however, suggests that once turned into a killer, “peace” is an
enemy, because a destroyer of life can’t live in a world without killing. Later
they chant in their underwear that the rifle is for killing, and their penises,
which are called “guns,” because they also are made to discharge, are for
“fun.” The comparing of the male organ with a gun is made obvious here, and
emphasizes how men have equated their male sexuality with how well they can use
a gun. In a sense, the symbolism suggests masturbation, with the male cut off
from others, and only needing himself for satisfaction. In a way, the soldier
here is joined to an inanimate destructive tool. He is supposed to transform
into an unstoppable force that wears a deadly “full metal jacket” loaded with
bullets.
The film does present the
counter argument for the need to turn men into a community that transcends
individuality. Hartman says at graduation, “Today, you are Marines. You’re part
of a brotherhood. From now on until the day you die, wherever you are, every
Marine is your brother. Most of you will go to Vietnam. Some of you will not
come back. But always remember this: Marines die. That’s what we’re here for.
But the Marine Corps lives forever. And that means you live forever.” The main character, Joker (Matthew Modine), the
journalist who occasionally provides a narrative voice, also talks about
transcendence when he says, “The Marine Corps does not want robots. The Marine
Corps wants killers. The Marine Corps wants to build indestructible men, men
without fear.”
Joker is a character who
shows conflicting sides. He says he joined the Marines to be a killer, but
makes fun of the gung-ho mentality of Hartman, doing a John Wayne impression.
He stands up to the drill instructor, and Hartman says, “Joker is silly and
ignorant, but he has guts, and guts is enough.” So, Hartman assigns him the
task of training Leonard, whose name the drill instructor has changed to Pyle
(Vincent D’Onofrio), the silly Marine character in the TV show Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C. Pyle is overweight
and has a childlike aspect to him, sporting an innocent grin. There are some
men who should not be turned into a killer because it is too traumatic a
metamorphosis. Pyle is such a person. Besides heaping insults on him, Hartman
makes him march with his pants down while sucking his thumb. As a punishment,
he forces Pyle to fall forward on his knees into the Marine’s hands so he can
be choked. This image is a forceful one, showing the self-destructive side of
this brutal training. This aspect comes to full fruition later. Hartman
punishes the rest of the unit for Pyle’s failures, emphasizing in a way how the
weakest link undermines the group. So, the men hold a “sock party” where they
wrap bars of soap around towels and beat Pyle at bedtime. The scene shows how
the sadism flows downward through the ranks. But, Joker’s compassionate side is
disgusted with the attack since he covers his ears because he doesn’t want to
hear Pyle’s painful crying.
Pyle starts to get with the
program, but he is now damaged goods. The most ironic scene in the movie occurs
when Hartman talks about the shooting ability of ex-Marine mass murderer
Charles Whitman and President Kennedy’s assassin Lee Harvey Oswald. He says,
“Those individuals showed what one motivated marine and his rifle can do. And
before you ladies leave my island, you will be able to do the same thing.” With
those words, we hear the danger of creating deadly men of war, who are so cut
off from their humanity that they become suicidal weapons which aim themselves
at their own citizens. After hearing Hartman’s words, Pyle looks battered. A
foreshadowing of what is to come occurs when Pyle shows promise on the firing
range and Hartman says, “Outstanding, Private Pyle. I think we finally found something
that you do well.” On the last night of basic training, Joker finds Pyle in the
head, loading his “full metal jacket.” When Joker warns him that they will be
in a “world of shit” if they are found there, Pyle responds by saying, “I am in
a world of shit.” The fact that he is in the bathroom just stresses the image. He
no longer has that innocent grin. His mouth is in a snarl, his eyes look
demonic. After loudly calling out rifle drill commands, Hartman shows up, so
much the military man that while in his underwear he still wears his drill
instructor hat. His demeaning yelling just provokes Pyle, who shoots Hartman
dead, and then turns the rifle on himself, providing a climax for the images of
self-destruction.
The story shifts to Vietnam,
where Joker works as a journalist for Stars
and Stripes with a photographer, Rafterman (Kevin Major Howard). Joker
continues his cynical humor when confronting his superior officer, Lt. Lockhart
(another unfeeling symbolic name) (John Terry), who ignores his warning about
the upcoming Tet Offensive by the enemy. There is a 1984 revamping of facts feel to Lockhart as he uses euphemisms to
describe wartime activities. For example, the term “search and destroy” becomes
“sweep and clear.” He wants a war story about death to be re-written with a
“happy ending.” Joker says sarcastically that he came to Vietnam, “to meet
interesting and stimulating people of an ancient culture … and kill them. I
wanted to be the first kid on my block to get a confirmed kill.” Notice the ironic
juxtaposition of the child toward a hopeful aspiration that turns out to be an
act of destruction. After the Tet Offensive, Joker and Rafterman leave Da Nang
to cover the action near the city of Hue. On the helicopter ride, they
encounter a door gunner who illustrates the barbarity of war as he gleefully
and indiscriminately kills civilians and Viet Cong, because in modern war it is
difficult to tell who is the enemy. But, he also has no problem killing women
and children. This a prescient scene, because, as we see in American Sniper, sometimes some women and
children can also be a threat.
There is a scene which
exemplifies the imperialism and self-righteous attitude of America in this war.
A colonel tells Joker that “all I’ve ever asked of my marines is that they obey
my orders as if they would the word of God.” This statement is revealing here,
because it shows the military man’s assumption that accepting his arrogant
equating of himself with God is no big request. He then says, “We are here to
help the Vietnamese, because inside every gook is an American trying to get out
… We gotta keep our heads until this peace phase blows over.” The bigoted and
presumptive belief here is that the whole Asian world is just an aberration, a
disease that, once cured, will allow that the only true healthy way to live is
the one prescribed by the United States. The idea of waiting for the “peace
phase” to blow over echoes the earlier statement by Hartman that for soldiers
made to become killers, peace itself, ironically, is the enemy.
We do have a scene of a grave
containing twenty civilians who were killed by the Viet Cong, showing the
barbarity of the enemy. So, in the final sequence we see the war from a
soldier’s point of view, where these men have to deal with the deadly shots of
a sniper who tries to draw them out by killing individual soldiers as they try
to rescue injured comrades. The sniper picks off some of the men, including
Cowboy, with deadly precision. The men finally corner the killer, who turns out
to be a teenage girl. This fact undercuts ironically Hartman’s speech about how
deadly one well-trained Marine can be. Here, the enemy can be just as lethal,
and all it takes is a motivated female child. Rafterman wounds her. Animal
Mother just wants to leave her in her writhing agony. In an act of both mercy
and cruelty, Joker kills her.
The next film is Shakespeare in Love.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please share your thoughts about the movies discussed here.